| Name of Horse | Owner | Description | Other Note(s) |
| Captain | Albert George Benson | 1000 lb., black
|
Bought from Stephen Barfitt, Long Beach; several times, it was known to have walked from St. Jones Within to Hatchet Cove (Baker’s Point) and swim across the Arm back to its “native home”;
Was “balky”; |
| Bon | Albert George Benson | 600 lb., red
|
|
| Molly | Albert George Benson | ||
| Star | Albert George Benson | Bought from Jack Robbins | |
| Catherine | Albert George Benson | ||
| Dolly | David Benson | 500 lb., white | Had her for 31 years |
| Kitty | David Benson | 500 lb., black | |
| Molly | David Benson | ||
| Charlie | David Benson | Bought from Wm. George Stringer, L. H. Ease | |
| Jim | Esau Benson | ||
| Girl | Albert Brown | 850 lb., red | |
| Beaut | Albert Brown | 850 lb., black | |
| Bully | Chesley Brown | 500 lb., red | Bought from Allan Tucker |
| Don | Chesley Brown | 500 lb., red | Bought from Will Robbins |
| Smoky | George Brown | 450 lb., black | |
| Grin | Jim Brown | 600 lb., white | Bought at L. H. E. |
| Beaut | Jim Brown | 500 lb., black | |
| Remington | Kayla Brown | 800 lb., gray | Newfoundland pony, brought from out west |
| Knight | Kayla Brown | 800 lb., gray | Newfoundland pony, brought from out west |
| Rain | Kayla Brown | 1100 lb., | Brought from Alberta |
| Kit | Walter Butt | ||
| Bell | Elijah Hillyard | 600 lb., red | |
| Prince | Lawrence Hillyard | 1000 lb., brown | |
| Patsy | Will Hillyard | 1000 lb., black | |
| Prince | Will Hillyard | ||
| Gin | Will Hillyard | Sold to Heber King | |
| Girl | Edgar Holloway | ||
| Shirley | Isaac Holloway | 700 lb., gray | |
| Pete | Isaac Holloway | 500 lb., black | |
| Flirt | Stephen Holloway | 500 lb., white | |
| Girl | Stephen Holloway | 700 lb., red | |
| Gin | Stephen Holloway | Bought from Heber King | |
| Bonnie | Alphaeus King | 500 lb., black | |
| Bess | Bill King | 600 lb., black | |
| Nelson | Boyd King | ||
| Clyde | Boyd King | ||
| Silas | Boyd King | ||
| Charlie | Ches King | Bought as a foal from Jack Brown, Hatchet Cove | |
| Lightning | Ches King | Came from Earles in Carbonear | |
| Bell | King, Gilbert | 700 lb., black | Came from Little Heart’s Ease |
| Bride | Guy & Otto King | 500 lb., black | |
| Lindsay | Guy & Otto King | 700 lb., brown | |
| Winston | Guy & Otto King | 800 lb., red | |
| Prince | Heber King | 700 lb., red | |
| Bess | Heber King | Bought at Trinity; was brought to St. Jones Within on the Norma & Gladys on her first voyage to this port | |
| Ginn | Heber King | Bought from Will Hillyard; later sold to Steven Holloway | |
| Frank | Wm. John King | 800 lb., white | |
| Clyde | George Miller | 600 lb., red | Sold to Adam Rodgers |
| Prince | George Miller | 800 lb., black | |
| Philly | Miller, Hezekiah | 600 lb., red | Superman |
| Prince | Eliab Robbins | 700 lb., brown | |
| Star | Jack Robbins | 500 lb., white | Sold it to Albert George Benson |
| Darby | Will Robbins | 2000 lb., black | Brought from the lumberwoods |
| Phil | Will Robbins | 700 lb., black | |
| Don | Will Robbins | Sold to Ches Brown | |
| Clyde | Adam/Bill Rodgers | 600 lb., red | Bought from George Miller |
| Queen | Reuben Toope | 600 lb., brown | Bought from Will Robbins |
| Flirt | Reuben Toope | 500 lb., white | Bought from Stephen Holloway |
| Molly | Allan Tucker | 700 lb., black | |
| Prince | Allan Tucker | 700 lb., red | |
| Rebel | David Tucker | 700 lb., gray | |
| Neice | Eli Tucker | 700 lb., red | |
| Whiskey | Harold Tucker | 600 lb., paint | |
| Lassie | Oliver Tucker | 700 lb., red | |
| Rex | Silas Tucker | 800 lb., black | |
| Molly | Silas Tucker | 800 lb., red | |