| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1874-1884 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1885-1889 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1890-1895 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1896-1900 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1901-1905 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1906-1910 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1911-1915 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1916-1917 |
| Anglican | St. Jones Without | 1885-1917 |
| Roman Catholic | Bonavista-Trinity Records | 1857-1918 |
| United Church | Random South | 1885-1894 |
| United Church | Random South | 1895-1899 |
| United Church | Random South | 1900-1909 |
| United Church | Random South | 1910-1914 |
| United Church | Random South | 1915-1918 |
| United Church | St. Jones Without | 1891-1918 |