| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1880-1889 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1890-1900 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1901-1910 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1911-1920 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1921-1930 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1931-1940 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1941-1950 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1951-1960 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1961-1970 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1971-1980 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1981-1990 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 1991-2000 |
| Anglican | Random South Parish | 2001- |
| Anglican | Fox Harbour, Southport, Gooseberry Cove, Butter Cove, Clay Pitts, and Little Harbour | 1880-1995 |
| Anglican and United Church | St. Jones Without | 1883-1949 |